Cincinnati, Ohio ODAR Office

At the Office of Disability Adjudication and Review (ODAR) in Cincinnati, Ohio, 12 different administrative law judges (ALJ) conduct Social Security Disability (SSD) hearings and Supplemental Security Income (SSI) hearings. Currently, in Cincinnati, the average wait time for a SSI or SSD hearing is 17.0 months. The average case processing time in Cincinnati is 595 days.The Cincinnati average for winning a SSI or SSD disibility hearing is 42%. Click on the name of one of the ALJs below to see detailed information about their hearing results. This information for the Cincinnati ODAR office was last updated on 6/11/2019.

Average statistics
OfficeJudgesAvg. Hearing
Wait Time
Processing Time
Per Day Per ALJ
Cincinnati 12 17.0 months 595 days 2.0 18% 42% 39%
Ohio15.4 months535 days2.317%39%43%
National Average:14.9 months500 days2.120%42%38%
Full NameDismissedApprovedDenied

LATEST COMMENTS         to leave your own comment, select a judge from the list above and leave a comment on that judge's page
Remonia Sloan
Judge: Jana Kinkade
3/24/2020 11:11:37 AM

I wish I didn't have judge kinkade she not a good judge to help people get there disability.

Judge: Matthew C Kawalek
3/5/2020 6:43:07 AM

I had a hearing scheduled for February 11, 2020, (after a grueling 3-1/2 year process), my attorney I were turned away my hearing cancelled, without notice or reschedy, due to a water leak in the building in Pueblo, Colorado... I'm having to beg plead fight to request an expedited rescheduled's March 12, 2020 as of yet only excuses about people out of Pueblo/Colorado springs offices and lack of availability and coordination with central scheduling. I'm desperately in need of my hearing, and feel there is not accountability by SSA or advocacy from attorney. I can't rate the judge yet, only the process trying to get a hearing with him... it's been exasperating disappointing slow and unfair. I feel like they just want me to die. Praying for a miracle.

Judge: Donald G Smith
2/16/2020 9:42:11 PM

if you come to his home and be a layer guess what. You are dipping your grave, because everything is on ink and paper. If you are a Veteran ,he will said THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE with eye contact. also your medical record and medical expert report its in the front of HONORABLE JUDGE. Every case are different . you must convince your self if you are DISABLE before you go to that HEARING and no make any excuse like: i do not speak english. HONORABLE JUDGE SMITH . THANK YOU SIR < THANK YOU YOUR HONOR and YOUR STAFF REAL PROFECIONAL

Judge: Matthew C Kawalek
12/5/2019 1:00:07 AM

Had my hearing the 2nd. He was Very fair and kind, still awaiting my Decision BUT i feel good about it!

Travis houston
Judge: Christopher S Tindale
11/6/2019 3:14:49 PM

Very poor judge. I went before him a long time back. I had been psychiatrically hospitalized 8 to 10 times before my hearing, and waited 6 months, only to be turned down. In my opinion, they should fire his ass. P.S I believe VERY heavily in karma.

Judge: Lloyd E Hubler III
9/25/2019 7:00:32 PM

Judge hubbler listened to me and was sincere and kind , a rare item in the odar judges a very nice man.

Judge: Thuy-Anh T Nguyen
8/28/2019 3:48:51 PM

I went before this judge a few weeks ago, waiting on her decision! I think she listened and didn't badger me or try and make me feel guilty for applying, she told me that it was her decision and she didn't have to go by social security decisions, which made me feel better. I just hope that I proved my son's case to her without a doubt, that's all I can hope for.

Scott Selby
Judge: Thuy-Anh T Nguyen
6/24/2019 10:36:25 AM

I am waiting. I am scared. I cannot keep borrowing money to keep the utilities on. In February, I had emergency surgery to replace my shunt. I was in hospital/rehab over a week. In March, about the time I was getting able to feed and dress myself, I collapsed in the shower. My shunt settings had to be adjusted. Luckily I only spent about 2 days in the hospital this time. I have been doing Physical and Occupational Therapy ever since. My wife has had to take time off of work to help take care of me: days, weeks, or months at a time. I can only hope that my case gets sent back here and that Judge Nguyen gives me a favorable decision this time. Otherwise, I don't know what to do. Who would hire me in my present condition? Again, even though it indicates below that your name is "optional", it is NOT

C. Glover
Judge: John M Prince
4/2/2019 5:58:05 PM

I sat before Judge Prince today as a witness on behalf of my cousins disability case. His demeanor did not make me nervous or uncomfortable at all. Even though he had to ask the questions and be thorough I do believe he has a compassionate soul. At the end of the day I believe the Lord ordered our steps. And I must say it was a pleasure to meet him.

I. Rangel
Judge: Ena Weathers
3/5/2019 8:49:37 PM

Esta Jueza es ********** y se ensaña en contra de las Personas y Pacientes incapacitados física y mentalmente, discriminando sin importar la enfermedad terminal que esté padeciendo. No debería estar ocupando ese puesto y tengan consideración de reconocer la necesidad de una real Jueza que Aplique la Ley realmente.

Judge: Donald G Smith
2/19/2019 3:24:10 PM

Judge Smith was nodding off during my entire hearing! How this man is a judge is beyond me. I’m opening an investigation into his misconduct & I hope others will come forward. There is no way he’s qualified to determine someone’s financial future when he can’t even stay awake for 30 minutes! These courtrooms have cameras on us, it’s high time they start recording the judges as well!

Scott Selby
Judge: Thuy-Anh T Nguyen
2/15/2019 3:17:25 PM

Got my official denial in January. My attorney has sent the paperwork on to the next level. I just got out of the hospital after brain surgery. But, anything new may not be admissible. So, even though I can't see straight, can't drive, and am not supposed to walk without supervision, I will probably be told I can go back to work; even though I haven't worked in over 10 years and have basically been stuck in my recliner or bed. Oh, this site says your name is optional, but it won't post unless you include it.

Kevin D Hendrix
Judge: Thuy-Anh T Nguyen
2/12/2019 12:50:00 PM

she seemed nice enough, but my attorney has been preparing me to lose ever since we knew before christmas that we drew her. With my arthritis and deafness and tinnitus, between the judge and the vocational expert, they have managed to come with work i can do! My Cancer is out of remission(just found out 2 weeks ago) but not long enough to merit disability since it's only the third time, and unless your are terminal, you can work with cancer and even if its terminal, you can still work up until a certain point....right? I've been living with family and friends since i lost my apartment back in sept of 2018 and since i've been back in Cincinnati on Jan 11th, i've been homeless, and have been spending the last of my money i get from a 30% military disability pension on a cheap motel for myself and my 2 emotional support dogs! i've not worked in 2 years, and i can't work enough to support myself with my severe hearing loss and not being able to bend and lift. My platelets are so bad in my blood that a slap on my arm breaks the skin and makes me bleed, but that is just a matter of stoping what your doing and put a band aid on. I have 2 sets or hearing aids from the VA and there of no use to me because they can't fix the ringing in my ears! I been seen by psychologist and told i have some disorders that will keep me for seeking gainful employment , but my attorney could not argue that point as he said this judge just wouldn't hear it! I won't get my official turndown for a few months and there is no appeal as my attorney told me "we are the public defenders of SSDI" and with this judge, you only get one shot. As long as the economy is good, between her and the vocational expert, there is no such thing as ssdi , basically if you have no arms and no legs, and are in a wheel chair, they can find you something like an opening at great american ballpark this summer, where you can flop out of your wheel chair and lay on the base path and be one of the bases!

Judge: William Diggs
1/25/2019 1:20:15 PM

I found William Diggs fair and reasonable and felt satisfied in his hearing of my case. He issued me a favorable decision about six weeks after the hearing. I had to wait two and a half years to get a hearing (though this wait time is not the fault of the judge). I felt all questions asked of me by Judge Diggs were reasonable and he was kind.

Judge: Steven Collins
12/6/2018 10:03:40 AM

Judge Collins was over my case. He was very nice and explained everything to me. I have depression and anxiety. My mind goes blank when I start feeling anxiety but he was very nice to me.

Anthony Jackson
Judge: Lloyd E Hubler III
11/23/2018 9:46:17 PM

I think it sad to go through so much to prove your disable when you work 34 years of your life two jobs combined over 21years making over 40 grand a year to settle for disability and get denied oh by the way I'm 49years old delever furniture back back and knees had surgery on one need on other first surgery is still bad so I'm not having the other surgery two herniated disc and sciatic nerve

Anthony Jackson
Judge: Lloyd E Hubler III
11/20/2018 6:19:20 PM

Judge Hubler was nice and he seems to be a fare judge seems concerned about your situation which is rare

Judge: William Diggs
11/14/2018 6:50:02 AM

Well just got denied, after 3 yrs of waiting and 4 yrs of not being able to work. I have found that this process is stacked against the citizens that have paid in their entire lives and when you need it they leave it up to a judge who doesn't know the everyday struggles you endure. As a combat vet I love my country but I am slowly beginning to think it could care less about me.

Judge: William Diggs
11/1/2018 6:03:50 AM

Judge Diggs, was very attentive, not throwing tuns of questions at random and seemed helpful and sympathetic. No negative responses about him.

Thomas Bennett
Judge: Anne Shaughnessy
10/30/2018 8:56:42 AM

Malfeasance: Brain Surgery, Mental confusion at times, Panic attacks, Depression, New Brain Tumor and Dementia. Unable to pass tests at Papa Johns without mgt help AFIB: Ireggular Heartbeat, forced to go to work, to remain out if a shelter and wrecked into a woman during AFIB and confusion. Reactive Airway: Can't be around many chemical irritants. Severe reaction, HUD OFFICE refused to let me fill out paperwork elsewhere to avoid Triggers. Left ball games, work, children and family homes. Doctor instruction to avoid. I REMAINED HOMELESS. Lived in a jeep. BACK. Degenerative disk disease, nerve root impingement and compression, Spinal Stenosis, recurring Annular Tear, Buldging disks and more backed up by MRI EVIDENCE 2007 AND 2016 and 3 doctors. Can't stand and can't sit for extended periods. Goes back to 2001. New case, Medicaid cancelled....NO ADDRESS. MRI Cancelled, moved to different area to stay w 1 daughter. VERY VERY TEMP. INSYRANCE CANCELLED ZERO INCOME Very hard on AFIB STRESS AND COPD 552 pages ER visits. Lost Several Jobs up to 48,000 plus plus couldn't stand. Became homeless after spending money marked for retirement and unable to continue PT job at Papa John. Malfeasance: Somewhere? Attorney?,Govt? The Process? Political motivation?,

Judge: Anne Shaughnessy
10/30/2018 7:42:06 AM

Malfeasance: Brain Surgery New brain tumor Confusion ModSevere degenerative disease Nerve root compression Spinal stenosis Afib Depression Panic attacks Bulging disks Annular tears 15 years of proof Reactive Airway disease All present except new tumor. 30 years as restaurant GM and business owner. I became homeless, shot at, lived in jeep for months. Malfeasance, attorney or Government?

Mark mansell
Judge: Cristen Meadows
10/23/2018 7:58:34 PM

I think they work hard.over worked...when I go to court on November 5,i will respect there decision.

Judge: Renita K Bivins
9/12/2018 8:36:18 PM

Renita K Bivins seems like a nice judge when you first go in there but beware because she is a ******** *****. There is a reason her approval rating is so low. She would not let me bring a family member in for emotional support, and she barely asked me any questions so it seemed she had her mind made up against me before my time to plead my case had even came. I knew enough to know to start volunteering information that I wanted the SSA to know because she wasn't asking. She didn't care that my doctor has been seeing me for years and the testimonials of my family members who know me best. She twisted anything I actually did say into a reason why I am able to work. If you drive then you comprehend the law and can follow direction so beware of that and god forbid you feed yourself. If you are unlucky enough to get this judge then I recommend you moving to another district or starting over with a new case because she will not approve you. She should not be a judge at all. Don't let her polite exterior fool you she is a *****.

Judge: Matthew C Kawalek
9/10/2018 3:37:07 PM

58 years old, in congestive heart failure with a 25% ejection fraction, lymphoma survivor and traumatic brain injured and you think I can lift 50 pounds for 1/3 of a day and 25 pounds for 2/3 of a day?

Tina trueblood
Judge: Monica LaPolt
9/4/2018 8:11:43 AM

Good morning I don't know if you are going to be my judge. I just want to. Let you know I sit in. Pain daily. Cannot have a good time with my grandkids and family. I wish I could. Get my claim approved. I sit daily and cry cause I can't do the things I used to. I can't drive long. If I clean I'm down for 4day. I been falling down studdering this is all new too me. I have a lawer I thought getting one would help me. I have had back surgery. I have manic depression bypolar. I'm really sorry to bother you. Welfare told me to apply years ago but I didn't want to cause there's others that need it. Now I have applied and the wait is terrible. I'm sorry hunny.

Rick S.
Judge: Anne Shaughnessy
8/12/2018 9:17:28 PM

An absolutely unfair and horrible judge. Made a mockery of my environmental issues in her final report. If you get this judge you really picked the booby prize. She will rip you and make you out to be some liar. I'd rate her in the negative numbers if I could.

Judge: Christopher S Tindale
5/22/2018 1:09:21 PM

He has a very low approval rating for a judge and a long wait time to get a decision. I waited 6 months just to find out I was denied by him and I walk on a prescribed walker and have medical evidence to back me. I guess you need to fake it to be approved by this judge instead of truly sick.

Donald Harris
Judge: Christopher S Tindale
4/21/2018 12:22:03 PM

Hee's very fair he listens to everything . That's said he made me feel at ease When I walked into the Courtroom I di d not know what 2 expect Now I'm waiting on the Decision

Judge: Robert W Flynn
3/17/2018 4:41:45 PM

How can I get ahold of judge Flynn? Already posted a comment. People in NY where in still stranded are being u ethical and spa is trying to gene away my SSI and become the rep payee which I know is illegal ... Being made to look homeless. Been gangstalked for 6 years with police brutality and everything stolen in Ky. No one will do the right thing? Entrapment and equivalent to human trafficking. Where my car is the guy is threatened to sell it with all sorts of evidence. Would end up killing me: foodstamps stolen and the fine is up to 8.1 million dollars and 550 yrs in jail APS Ny refuses to investigate . APS is threatening to discharge me to a shelter instead of resolving the issue of the past 6 years im not eligible for housing in NY state and have animals with me which is my right. A shelter is not an option it's a 2 day bandaid fix for in stare residents. People have basically done the equivalent to human trafficking. Lawyers in my know what's happening and refuse to deal with reality.,police tied me up and tazered my teeth out and burned my feet. bribg blocked from credible people. My phone stolen and only have free wifi temporarily. People said my mom is dead and I know she's not. They told me 15 other people are dead that aren't either: I e received letters to try to scare me. What will people's cibsswyebses be??? Worse than murder 1. What the hell am u supposed to do??? I have 2 masters plus and intend to go back to vet school to get my DVM at Yale or Harvard. APS is part of a scam .....people don't threatened to not do the right thing .... I have a copy of an appeal and they are lying saying the govr lost the paperwork which is crazy on their part: except i sent a copy to civil rights in Washington, D.C. And have. Copy too., what the ****????? M. A. Kramer AS, BA, MSS, LCSW, M.ED

Phillip W
Judge: Donald G Smith
1/18/2018 6:53:13 AM

1/8/2018 Very fair and professional in mannerisms. Put me at ease and made answering questions less stressful. Whole staff courteous and polite.

Phillip W
Judge: Donald G Smith
1/18/2018 6:51:08 AM

1/8/2018 Very fair and professional in mannerisms. Kentucky charm made put me at ease and made answering questions less stressful. Whole staff courteous and polite.

Holly M.
Judge: Donald G Smith
12/6/2017 3:15:54 PM

I had a great experience with Judge Smith! I waited 7 years to get my disability and just happened to have he hardest judge the first time. With Smith he listened to me very intently and he was Curtious and fair. He approved me right there but did not want to step on the previous judges toes so he gave me 32 months backpay with full benefits. He’s ranked right in the middle of being a fair judge and that he is! Thank you Judge Smith for everything. I know your job is hard and I appreciate how you handled my case. People you better have your doctors on top of all of their paperwork and you better have a darn good reason for coming to see him for disability.

M. Anne Kramer,AS,BA, MSS, LCSW, M.ED
Judge: Robert W Flynn
12/6/2017 6:09:19 AM

I was granted SSI through Judge Flynn/ with my disability lawyer Lisa Clark. I am the beneficiary of my benefits. I have not had a problem with SSI until now..I've had identity theft, am a KY resident and traveling out of state. My car broke down and I am stuck in upstate NY. The ssa office and Adult protective services have been totally unethical! I am a licensed clinical social worker and teacher and know the laws! I know housing isn't available through social services if you are an out of state resident. To become a state resident you have to transfer car license, registration, insurance which would cost me approx 1000.00 that I don't have!!! I had cancer while living in KY lost my house I owned in Covington to move to Boone Co. It ended up being an absentee landlord scam. Everything I own was stolen. I know some of who's involved. I went to do a formal complaint and police refused to take it/ said I had no rights, they refused to help me, and said if I didn't do what they wanted I'd be arrested?? I have been gangstalked for 5 horrible years!!!! I was physically abused by police too: tied up in a metal chair and thrown on my face... Had teeth disintegrated laZer tazered out, Also feet burned.,??? I have photos.,I had Attorney Bob Lotz KY call me and say first time in 30 years I mistakenly gave your file to bad people??? Then his firm totally irresponsible?? Cincinnati police said Boone co is known for drugs and prostitution??? I'm not a part of it. Judge Tracy Wise doesn't reside in Boone and Kenton co/ my bankruptcy wasn't done properly in Covington/ Michael Plummer. All of these people are unavailable to correct any problem??? There are local people in Ohio and ky involved in gangstslking that are still hassling me!! I'm being made to look homeless. Some of my antiques are in Florence antique mall Bob Hills booth.,When I complained he's unethical and attached to the police covering up the scam.,I paid for the rental through Sibcy Cline: proved it with receipts at legal aid: and their comment on Covington was " they decided to pass you around?" What the ****?? Laws are being ignored: total disrespect!!! Some adult protective service worker showed up 3x's without me initiating it, and not being a ny state resident with no intention of becoming one.,the office APS/ DSS rebesselaer co have been unethical violated my civil rights And broken laws... Trying to manipulate me to live in upstate NY??? Lisa Pettis adult protective services said to me while I was visiting a park ( not living there like she accused me of) that if I didn't return to ky to get my mail from ssa that is loose my benefits????? How would she know thus? I explicitly said I was uncomfortable giving her any personal info. She behind my back with no intake, no signature, no contract etc after I complained about her to Troy's ssa office... She applied to be my payee????? That is crazy, identity theft, crazy!!!! I don't need any help managing money..All of a sudden instead of the Troy ny office taking my side they said there had to be a hearing????? Not if you already granted me SSI when I hired Lisa Clark as ny disability lawyer to akways represent me for accountability purposes!!! It took two years to see you with independent medical examiners etc . This process is not just negated by an underling without a judge/ and me being an out of state resident the entire thing shouldn't be an issue!!! I went to call Florence ky office ssa to find they had a hearing without me there with no paperwork not knowing me,,behind my back, with wrongful accusations????? No way!!!!!!! I know the laws. The Troy ssa worker Jessica said for me not to cone back to the Troy office to deal with APS/DSS who's the problem!!! This past summer I stayed in a pet friendly hotel and paid for it then went camping to save moved for my car repairs so money management isn't my problem!!!Having a payee is not appropriate at all!!! The car repairs are expensive and I need the SSI direct deposited like it has been!!! How did Lisa Pettis get into my personal bank acct??? I contacted them and the FDIC to complain..she had no info.. Knowing my car is broken down for a ny adult protective services worker to say I have to return to ky to get my mail or my SSI will stop????? How would I get there?? A total manipulation!! How would she know about SSI and my mail from ky,,,???? A huge premeditated malicious manipulstion not to help but the total opposite to not resolve the Past 5 years of gangstslking police brutality as acknowledged by master commissioner and attorney Len Rowrkamp ky.....I also went to Albany Co, called Renesselaer co and Columbia co DSS this past summer they refused to help me....not a state resident. Waiting list 3-4 months and no pets.Now all of a sudden with me being a ky resident with car problems with no intention of living here the new manipulation is if I don't tell Renesselaer co Where I'm going or living I can't have my SSI money??? They are creating an undue hardship and being unlawful. I'm not accountable to out of state people!!!!! This is craziness!!!!! I Sent a bunch of emails all unanswered .. Then finally the email says before a hearing they will continue to give you SSI. Their newest unethical manipulation wrongly accusing me of being in Renesselaer co... Then involving other people more supervisors that aren't addressing the situation!!???? Gangstslking duty to inform the big picture... Made to look homeless, 200 IQ quite capable of money management / they are making it impossible for me to get my car fixed...said the SSI money is in the govt.????? Unless I tell them whete I'm going for some other payee I can't have my money back??? That is criminal and violates my civil rights and violates the contract already set up with you, and my disability lawyer!!!!i need you to intervene with SSI telling them u don't need a payee won't be manipulated to stay in ny state... I have no money because what I've been counting on they interfered with with none of my personal info or security questions to get into the SSI system!!! Major violations..!!! For an entire office in Troy NY to be acting so totally ignorantly with more people involved against my will equals a mega law suit to come!! I've complained to the inspector general, attorney general, federal trade commission, my disability lawyer's office. My EBT and ky Medicaid have also been scammed by gangstalkers making it even reported this numerous times with no resolve? My old cell was stolen and a 2700 bill run up/ police unwilling to take a report or Verizon or equixfax or Transunion???? This effected my car insurance rates and these people have also falsified documents / car insurance with no NAIC #???? I wrote to the insurance commission and the bogus letters I got back said " yes it is criminal and we aren't doing anything about it?" I was hit by a fedx truck who left the scene of the accident without providing his commercial license? I called fedx and they couldn't identity him??? Cops showed up after the fact and gave me a ticket??? Totally wrong!!!! More of the sane scapegoating?! Cancelled my insurance??? A ny police let me video him while he called dispatch and says my license was clear????? I've had unnecessary hassles . The SSI is urgent so is the gsngstalking! I need to find a powerful international lawyer my two expired passports were also stolen...... People from Canada I know are unfortunately Also involved I drove to the border as was denied the American Embassy/ that's another huge violation .... The sabotage is equivalent to human trafficking... Trying to make me destitute???? I need your intervention : know it wouldn't be a problem if I don't hear back with an immediate resolution this too was blocked!! I've tried to contact 42 credible people with no response??? There is no way that would happen!!! M.AnneKramer,AS,BA,MSS,LCSW,M.Ed. Note my phone will be off by early next week...need the SSI back with me as the beneficiary, a ky resident . My ky address is 700 Scott Street Suite 1002 Covington, KY. 41012 I'm stuck however in upstate NY so email is the current way to reach me 859-912-1353. Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter/ urgent and confidential / time is of the essence!

Been There, Done That
Judge: Kevin J Detherage
11/29/2017 1:41:34 PM

You will lose with this judge. Be prepared for an appeal. He clearly is looking to deny. Not fair or impartial. With an approval rating under 38% is well under the National Average. I hope he enjoys remands because they are coming his way.

Judge: Steven Collins
11/14/2017 9:35:30 AM

I went before this Judge yesterday. I was very nervous and he was very calming & kind. He explained the process to me and I felt like he was really weighing the evidence and had no preconceived ideas. Win or lose, I feel I was treated fairly.

Judge: Gregory G Kenyon
9/14/2017 7:09:00 PM

He is wonderful!!!!!!

M. Clinton
Judge: Renita K Bivins
8/15/2017 3:03:32 AM

Judge Bivins was fair on my case I really was expecting a different outcome. She was very nice and funny, do not under estimate her, she will get the job done as long as you tell her the truth she will definitely cross examines you. I had a great outcome. Good luck to you all.

Judge: Kevin J Detherage
7/17/2017 9:40:35 AM

His approval rating will fall into the 30s soon. Having practiced SSD law for over 30 years, I knew when I first appeared in front of him my claims were heading toward Appeals Council. He takes over the hearing and asks leading questions of your claimant that are calculated to provide the answers he wants to find against him or her. Now that the law allows judges like him to apply great weight to the opinions of the consultants, he will and already has utilized that rule to increase your client's RFC to a level that conveniently results in an unfavorable or partially favorable decision with no back pay. He will ignore additional limitations when he constructs his RFC and frames his hypothetical questions. Be ready to respond to this by crossing the vocational expert and point to specific exhibit numbers as the basis for additional limitations. You have to get your file ready for Federal Court as his denials are often no based on substantial evidence.

Judge: Dwight D Wilkerson
5/22/2017 11:28:44 AM

I have been waiting for him for 18 months and I know that even if I got the letter today I will still have to wait 75 days is there any way to speed this process up

Judge: Gregory G Kenyon
4/12/2017 7:09:44 PM

Judge kenyon was so very nice and understanding. He made me feel at ease when I was in room and answering his questions. Couldn't have had a better judge.

Judge: Monica LaPolt
3/27/2017 5:28:43 PM

This judge was down right rude, mean & made findings about me & my character based on a mistake in the paperwork! Completely unprofessional. She was so mean that even my lawyer couldn't believe it!

Judge: Matthew C Kawalek
3/27/2017 9:55:42 AM

I just received a fully favorable decision from Judge Kawalek. My Attorney advised me he was a fair judge and he was! I was nervous about my hearing after reading the above comment but I feel if your medical records are in order and you are truthful that is what matters most.

Tore the Decision to pieces
Judge: Matthew C Kawalek
3/7/2017 3:01:39 PM

He comes across as a "nice guy" and knowledgeable, as a Judge. look at his Decision and wonder whether he was even in the same Courtroom as you and whether he has ANY knowledge of the medical Cases he presides over, at the Disability level. You'll note(As of this writing.), that he has ONLY approved 37% of Disability Cases. It ISN'T due to much in false Disability claims, as he is an Appeals Judge. In order to go to Appeal, it must first be approved and THEN you must learn how to survive for anywhere from 12 months to 2 years to have your Case heard. In my situation, I have a wife and she(With Parkinson's Disease, Lupus and Fibromyalgia.) has been supporting our family since my disabilities prevented me from work. This is my 2nd time "through the ringer" with Disability Judges and this has been ongoing for almost FIVE YEARS(Almost 2, of which have been wasted, waiting on this "Judge" to write a 15 page, "clown car" Decision that had little to no reliance on the FACTS of the Case.). I wouldn't recommend this Judge, nor do I fid him as competent to do the job that was assigned "By the People", as he is all about preventing proper care, for those who aren't in need of ambulatory care on a daily basis. I have 2 diseases that are 1 in a million people, a "rash" that is "contained" under low physical stress(perspiration takes it to covering my body.), ongoing Hydradenitis(I get boils/infections that lead me to being hospitalized if I sit in one place too long, perspire too much.), spinal degeneration in my neck, upper, lower and middle of my spine and a myriad of other illnesses that combine with these things to make work...unattainable. Does it matter to him, sitting upon his "pulpit" of "Law"? Not at all. Back to the drawing board? No. On to the Judge Panel in a follow up Appeal. If they approve the medical problems, based on my experience over the past 5 years...not much in faith with this clown of a "system". Now for the biggest problem, with him: As if it isn't bad enough that one had to document anything and everything medically for Disability; this guy actually LIES about "Findings". A flippin' "Judge". SMH Even as you read through his Decision, you find him countering his OWN arguments, WITHIN the Decision. A quick, easy example would be me stating that I have a slight hearing problem(Not part of the Disability Case.) and needing the speakers adjusted for our Video Conference of which I set up nothing. I stated that I can/do go on the Web play a game, talk on rare occasion and have the comfort of my cushioned couch(Can't sit in any office chairs for extended periods, as they further deteriorate my spine and hurt within 10 minutes.) to be able to adjust as often necessary. From his Decision..I can sit in a office chair for a full day of work(No evidence ever presented to show this.), I can Video Conference Chat and am familiar with it(Never stated that, nor do I do it or know how to get beyond clicking on my video system, hitting record and having a short video.) and...I had to get them to move the speaker during our Conference, as I couldn't hear what he was saying. But...I must be an expert. RME Want the truth about Kawalek and the other Judges/Magistrates that do the Disability Hearings? They AREN'T required to have a Degree in ANYTHING medically related! I learned that from one of my old Primary Doctors, who had been part of Disability and was told/required that his OWN medical knowledge/opinion was NOT to be stated on Legal Documents, stating that a person is "Handicapped"(And similar wording.) as the ONLY person that could state it is...a Judge(No knowledge of medical required, nor needed.). The "system" is fictional and, in this Case, Judge Matthew C. Kawalek is one of the LEad Writers for the Fiction. Anyone wonder why "seemingly normal" people "turn to crime"? It's because the "System" forces them into that lifestyle, when it fails them at the Disability level. Fortunately, as stated prior, I have a wife who cares and provides just enough to scrape by. Anything less....I'd probably be being educated in some prison, FREE, and be receiving the PROPER medical care that most/all Inmates receive. When I came out...I'd HAVE Disability. What a joke of a "System" and "Judge", when a Disabled person can be "better off" by GOING to prison, over going to a Government Office. SMH@Both. P.S. IF this guy is your "Judge"...request a new Judge by yourself or through your attorney, as this guy is a flippin' joke.

Hector colon
Judge: Daniel Dadabo
1/31/2017 11:31:56 AM

Good man he listens to you very calm

Justice Seeker
Judge: Renita K Bivins
1/30/2017 5:54:33 PM


Gilbert Derriso
Judge: Gregory G Kenyon
1/28/2017 5:53:55 AM

Judge Kenyon was very fair in my case

Timothy J. Hoepf
Judge: Paul E Yerian
12/16/2016 11:52:29 AM

Administrative Law Judge, Paul E. Yerin: You, sir, ordered BACK an Overpayment back in December of 2014-15 in the amount of $2,985.00. That money was sent to me by a check when I had already received by mail and activated a new DIRECT EXPRESS CARD. Ms. Farrell and 200 N. High Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215 set me up for another Overpayment and I was barred out of the building and all other branches when I had just got back in good faith to enter and conduct my affairs prior to the Franklin County Jail. The OIG on it's website has in a link ( TOP SSA MANAGEMENT ISSUES). See (Report Fraud,Waste, or Abuse), link- Audits and Investigations. Out of seven topics two stand out. The first being safeguarding Social Security Numbers and the second being Overpayments. Ms. Farrell "disclosed" over the phone of Homeland Security Inspector, Jeremy Gumringer employee phone my SSA diagnosis and stated, "I should have a payee" on the 4th floor of the Appeals and Adjudication's Office after I got out of the Franklin County Jail. This SSA branch of 200 N. High Street in Columbus, Ohio receives daily reports of individuals incarcerated and the day that a person was sentenced with the particular Judge. Ms. Vandivier employed at this branch stated by phone to me that I need to prove to this office I was incarcerated and that I tried to Contact this branch. This Office receives daily and monthly reports generated to them automaticly or mechanicly. I received two (2) monthly checks in the amount of $733.00 for the month of January and Febuary of 2015 while incarcerated and I am entiled to the January check because I was NOT sentenced until January 8, 2015 with seventeen (17) days Jail Time Credit or (JTC). I spoke to a Captain; Beverly Huff; and Kelly with the Franklin County Sheriff's Department and received the slated dates and disposition - which this Office already had aquired. (See The 200 N. High Street SSA branch took $73.40 from June of 2015 to June of 2016, plus the remaining ORDERED BACK amount of $785.00 - which added to $2,199.00 equals the $2,984.00 that sir you ordered back. I am also entiled to the remaining amount of $785.00 - which sir, you Ordered back do to an Overpayment issue from the beginning that I never received. Thank you sir for your attention concerning this matter. Respectfully, Mr. Timothy J. Hoepf

regina grant
Judge: Anne Shaughnessy
12/13/2016 11:27:53 AM

I don't feel I was given a fair trial, because I feel she should ask me if I needed extended time to get another Attorney and she didn't, cause first I wouldn't refer Morgan&Justice to no one which gave it to Karen justice, who the said she was taking a job in another county , so now I have Mr. Stevenson who wants to start from scratch. I have all the proof from my doctors. I worked and paid into d's, this is bull.

Timothy J. Hoepf
Judge: Paul E Yerian
11/9/2016 3:53:23 PM

Judge Paul E. Yerin: my name is Timothy J. Hoepf and you sir decided an appeal in December of 2014 concerning an 'overpayment dispute' I had with the 200 N. High Street's SSA branch. You found in favor of me and ordered back the $2,984.00. I was sent only $2,199.00 of that Order and the same office put me back into Overpayment before I even got released out of the Franklin County Jail. I recently found out through a Captain from the Franklin County Sheriff's Office that there office generates an inmate count of everyone incarcerated. This sir would mean that all Social Security Offices' in Columbus, Ohio had prior knowledge of a beneficiaries incarceration date, but may still have put that individual's benefits in Overpayment status while they were in the Franklin County Jail. The women in the SSA office at N. High Street, Columbus, Ohio 43215 DO NOT IDENTIFY recipients of SSI benefits; even managers.

Judge: Renita K Bivins
8/10/2016 1:24:45 PM

Judge Bivins seem to be fair, from previous comments I was expecting a totally different person, she asked question and listen to my response, was rather nice, VE seem to be a little confused from the judge question, my case, my problem was the vocational so called expert, not an expert at all, hopefully he didn't hurt my case :(

Judge: Renita K Bivins
8/10/2016 1:24:11 PM

Judge Bivins seem to be fair, from previous comments I was expecting a totally different person, she asked question and listen to my response, was rather nice, VE seem to be a little confused from the judge question, my case, my problem was the vocational so called expert, not an expert at all, hopefully he didn't hurt my case :(

Judge: Steven Collins
6/30/2016 12:38:07 PM

I had this judge last month.... I have really bad panic attacks and hate being around people... He explained the whole process to me an was very sincere... Felt very comfortable for once.. Still waiting for my results... But either way... Great judge.

Alyssa Taylor
Judge: Kevin J Detherage
6/8/2016 1:41:12 PM

Fair and competent. An ASSET to ODAR!

Penélope Grace
Judge: Kevin J Detherage
6/8/2016 11:54:14 AM

Caring Outstanding Intelligent Fair Patient, THE BEST!

Judge: Renita K Bivins
5/11/2016 10:21:09 AM

This woman does not understand the most basic aspects of disability law. Her 10% approval rate is so far outside the national bell curve that SSA needs to investigate why she is so far outside the national average - to be approving no more than 10% of cases assigned to her when the national average for approvals is a bit over 50% should make it clear that something is terribly wrong with the way this woman adjudicates cases. Recently, she demanded that a dead claimant (died in 2014 and it took SSA until March 2016 to hold the hearing) amend his alleged onset date to the following year simply because the claimant had earned SGA prior to his alleged onset date! She seems to be under the impression that if a person earns more than the SGA threshold amount in a given year then that person cannot be found disabled at any time in that year! It is inexcusable that SSA would allow someone who lacks understanding of one of the most fundamental aspects of disability law to work as a judge and pay them over $160K a year to improperly deny meritorious cases up to 90% of the time. If your case is assigned to this judge, you need to move into another jurisdiction so you can transfer your file out from under this judge before your hearing takes place.

Jessica Heckle
Judge: Robert W Flynn
4/19/2016 2:40:08 PM

I just completed my hearing today and I have to say, whatever the decision is, Judge Flynn truly comes across as a fair and compassionate judge. This entire process has been so nerve wracking, but I felt at ease and, most importantly, listened to. Especially since I haven't been as fortunate to have as much therapy so far to deal with my anxiety and depression like I need to. So, regardless of the decision, I appreciate being treated with respect and compassion as this long journey winds to an end.

Judge: Renita K Bivins
3/9/2016 12:03:56 PM

I understand that in this day and time there is abuse to the system. I'm all for fairness and people not abusing the system. But Judge Bivins is ALL ABOUT the numbers so she can look good. She is the most uncompassionate person. She should take time to dive into people's lives and situations because she wants to deny on anything even if you can wash your own hair. She has no idea about mental concerns when a person has worked their whole life and they had a severe traumatic event happen to them that has left them barely surviving. I've been seen by the same doctor since my tragedy everything documented but Judge Bivins doesn't care that she is dealing with people's lives that are really in need and can ruin their life forever.

Shane humphries
Judge: Kenneth Wilson
3/7/2016 8:20:49 PM

Mr. wilson i honestly didnt mean any disrespect just put urself in my shoes fighting for four years an getting denied mostly because i dont have any medical insurance or any money an i cant go to the specialist an other doctors that i need to go to especially about my heart an the neck surgery needed to get an like me you couldnt get anyone to understand thats why i dont have these specific details that are needed an the thought of not seeing my kids an possibly by the time i get approved two of them is gonna be grown up an ive missed out on time ill never get back with them if i could work i would i hate all this everything that makes my life worth living i have lost because i am unable to work an the denials i got before this last one i had a place to live an was hanging on but i couldnt afford to get denied when i went in front of you in court i new that pretty much my life was in ur hands i know that sounds dramatic but its true an i have witnesses that will testify to my situation i even asked my lawyer if i could let you know all of that at the end of the hearing an she said it wasnt a good idea i just knowed if i would have ben you athen i would have wanted to know if my decision could possibly put a persons life in danger meaning me not having food of a way to go to the doctor an get my medication well i just thought i should double check an make sure you new i wasnt trying to be rude at all an i truly believe if another person was in my situation they would say what i have said an everything i have said is true if proof is eded i can prove utit an i hope you read these comments thank you for youre time.

Maintenance Electrician
Judge: Dwight D Wilkerson
12/12/2015 7:55:51 AM

Thank you Judge Wilkerson. I appreciate you taking the time to review my case and make your decision. I was very greatful when I got the decision. Thank you again for being a great Judge.

David Francy
Judge: Thuy-Anh T Nguyen
12/7/2015 11:29:48 AM

very thoughtful seemed to really listen. I am very nervous and hope to hear some good news before christmas.

Judge: Kenneth Wilson
11/10/2015 9:12:20 PM

Fair,thorough, very attentive to my case and I really appreciated this judge for treating me like a person. God bless.

Bill Olive
Judge: Dwight D Wilkerson
9/12/2015 8:49:10 PM

The VA would not submit the letter that would have granted me my disability, stating that it was a 'conflict of interest'. Only after I had a meeting with the VAMC administrator did they send the letter to this judge. There was no regulation or conflict of interest that prevented them from sending the letter. However, the judge made his decision 5 days prior to the release of this letter. Thanks VA! Now I lose my house, my car, and my child will be homeless while in her senior year of high school. She is an AP honors student and will be homeless. I worked for 35 years. Served my country. SSA's own doctor said I was disabled, the vocational expert said there were no jobs in the economy for me, yet the VA and this judge made a horrible decision. Time for the media and the VA OIG to get involved.

Nancy C
Judge: John M Prince
8/12/2015 8:17:14 AM

I was belittled by This judge. My hearing was done via video because I was in Kentucky. I can honestly say that Within the first few minutes of the hearing I felt I had no chance of winning. He was just going through the motions, but clearly had his mind made up even before I answered the the first few questions. This was not the worst part. During the disability and disclosure process you have to answer (honestly) all questions put to by your attorney. He asked if I did any drugs. I had back in my 20's but not since. This judge actually said this question has nothing to do with your case, but I see here you did drugs at one time. He said the name of the drug and literally snickered and asked me why I did it and what it was like. I was in shock and felt like he used his POWER to make me reveal information that was clearly something he did not need for me admit on record. It's bad enough to feel guilty about some decisions you made 30 years ago, but to have it brought out and put on record and feeling it was done clearly for his enjoyment was nothing short of horrendous for me. I walked out feeling humiliated and started crying immediately after as I walked out of the door. I received my judgement one week after the hearing. I am appealing his decision. It is my right to decline a video hearing, so I will never have to face John Prince again.

Judge: Peter Jamison
7/28/2015 12:28:45 PM

Too early to know the decision, but Judge Jamison was very kind during the hearing, really putting the claimant at ease. He was patient with her and took time to really explain everything.

Judge: Monica LaPolt
6/16/2015 1:50:02 PM

This judge is a joke, and I haven't even been in front of her yet. A "Peggy" in her office just called and told me that I had to come downtown, taking a day unpaid off work, bring my daughter (who has Down Syndrome) to show them that my daughter is disabled. As if the doctors letter showing her as having Down Syndrome wasn't enough! What does this judge think? She lost her extra chromosome since we filed the paperwork? Not only that but my wife has to take an unpaid day off work as well because someone needs to be there to take care of our daughter during the remainder of the session. All of this after 15 months of waiting for this judge to hear the appeal, and cancelling once, within 7 days of the initial appointment. It's no wonder people hate the government so much, if all government employees are as incompetent as this I now know why.

Judge: Gregory G Kenyon
5/14/2015 3:09:41 PM

This man was the kindest most caring individual I have come in contact with during the whole disability process. I never imagined a judge being so kind and reassuring. This Judge is fair and made me feel like my life had some hope. Thank you Judge Kenyon!

Sharon Smith
Judge: Kenneth Wilson
2/1/2015 9:27:35 AM

5 star good judge

Judge: Renita K Bivins
1/29/2015 9:18:44 AM

Judge Renita K Bivins Is very investigative and comprehensive. She is fair if the evidence and testimony match. She is very concerned about doing her job by the book.

Alexander Christian Ellis
Judge: Gregory G Kenyon
11/11/2014 12:52:17 PM

Thank you, Judge Gregory G Kenyon and staff for hearing my case and also expediting my case. I am very grateful. Sincerely, Alexander Christian Ellis

dorothy hauser
Judge: John M Prince
10/19/2014 3:00:38 AM

My husbands judge very nice calm and understood everything you said to him. Very respectful judge. His attorney told him he is a really great judge. And he was right.

Judge: Monica LaPolt
10/2/2014 7:12:41 AM

She runs a fair hearing but is severe in her rulings with a low approval rate. Not an ALJ you necessarily want to be in front of with anything but a very good case.

Shanun Lock
Judge: Kevin J Detherage
8/29/2014 8:25:18 AM

Judge Kevin Detherage is a very fair and equitable judge he listens attentively to all his cases and makes his decisions according to the law I respect that. S. Lock

Judge: Kevin J Detherage
8/13/2014 10:32:23 AM

It was nice to see this judge seemed to care and actually spent the time to try and understand my issues and why I in front of him instead of an "in-out" case like ordering a meal at mcdonalds.

Judge: Paul E Yerian
8/4/2014 4:49:47 PM

Judge: Paul E Yerian
8/4/2014 4:48:20 PM

I'm very please that Judge Yerian did a OTR decision for me. I appreciate the hard work that goes into each case file he must go through.

broken back
Judge: Renita K Bivins
7/28/2014 4:43:33 AM

Judge Bivins is not a fair Judge, she picks one line out of the full medical report from 13 doctors that says you are disabled and denies your case saying that there has to be a job that you are able to do out there that will allow to to take breaks every thirty minutes to lay down for thirty minutes. I'm sorry but common sense says that no employer is going to allow you to do that. For a Judge , she's the dumbest i have ever seen and needs to be replaced instead of our tax dollars paying her , ( to obliviously lay down when ever she wants)

Judge: Renita K Bivins
7/17/2014 6:42:51 PM

Buckle your seatbelts for this one had court with Judge Bivins today very thourough and she goes by her script she will try to find the most easiest job for you to prove her case against even having a listing that should automatically qualify you for disability. She will cross examine you like a prosecutor so good luck and she is new to Covington Ga

Kelley Greer
Judge: Monica LaPolt
6/26/2014 12:57:28 PM

After having a hearing with this ALJ which doesn't impress me that she is even considered a judge! After reading reviews on this gal, how is she still a so called "Judge?" She lied right to my face under oath at my hearing! Does she NOT know that is perjury? This gal needs to lose her title, and her job with her dishonest behavior! I was lied to by several in this office and nobody knows what they are doing! I've taken my complaint higher to the Indiana Bar, I would be happy to see this gal lose her job and legal license! Unreal!! Why is a "judge" allowed to lie??? I shall keep you posted that whole office needs to be investigated and further more-jobless!! Give the jobs to honest Americans that wl do the job!! Sometimes authority gets ya "judge!"

Kathy D. McQueen
Judge: Kevin J Detherage
6/23/2014 12:04:26 PM

I think Judge Kevin J. Detherage is an outstanding judge. Wishing him all the best in Ohio!!!

Natalie R
Judge: Gregory G Kenyon
6/15/2014 5:22:13 AM

I agree with Approved a Thank a The Lord..... I do not know how it will turn out but can say I think he is more fair than SS people, who led me astray in circles for years, false info etc.... Which has cost me dearly in so many ways. Judge Kenyon, made me feel at ease I was terrified, but his kindness and caring way helped so much. Thank You for your time sir.n nNatalie R

Judge: Paul E Yerian
5/30/2014 10:51:20 AM

Why is he so slow ....... Been nearly 2 years and still no answer.

Andrew Atkinson
Judge: Kenneth Wilson
5/22/2014 1:40:18 PM

Judge treated my wife with the upmost respect. Friendly & fair.

Judge: John M Prince
5/14/2014 9:12:23 AM

He was genuinely compassionate, attentive, and it appeared that he wanted to do all he could to help disabled individuals.

Judge: Deborah Smith
4/29/2014 1:42:29 PM

I stood before Judge Smith. I was one of the average 57 to 58 percent denied every year. Two of my personal Doctors found me disabled. She gave them, "No weight" in her words. She did give the paid SSA paid Doctor who never examined me "full weight". That has been several years ago. I still can not work and have not worked for every one of those years. I made 50 thousand a year. Now I make nothing, with no disability. Judge Smith let me down. The comments of "honest and fair" of the previous post are the only reason I left this. If the Judge reads this, I wish she could know what I have suffered because of her judgement. I have not worked in ten years now and everything is on the shoulders of my wife. I hope it was just a poor judgement and not meeting denial numbers.

Judge: Monica LaPolt
4/6/2014 5:36:05 AM

She dismissed my doctors recommendations and decided to think she was my doctors. Denied by her with untrue things in denial letter. I really think she didn't read my file right as she stated as she said I was still doing some hobbies which it clearly stated I have not done them in years. Anyway federal appeal ruled she was wrong so that tells you right there she doesn't do her job right and should find another job. If denied by her take it to federal and you will win.

Judge: Paul E Yerian
3/17/2014 8:39:37 AM

It appears he is very slow at his reviews.. He has asked again to speak with me at the hearing office.

Sharon Hummel
Judge: Monica LaPolt
3/10/2014 2:18:35 PM

This judge is a joke! She threw out or had a negative response to everything in my file. I couldn't believe the untrue or negative responses in my denial letter. Someone isn't doing their job properly. Threw out both of my doctors responses, said I was a liar, my daughter and sister. I am very sick have been for a long time now and no one will help me. I am about to loose my house and anything I have. I have worked my entire life very hard and to be treated like this is a insult. This judge needs replaced. They need to take in to account their responses. I would be interested in knowing how many suicides occur from judges and doctors that seem like their only goal is to kick you when your down. Be a professional like you are supposed to be!!!! I am very angry how good people are treated from judges and doctors, people we are suppose to respect.

Judge: Larry A Temin
2/24/2014 1:45:30 PM

I thought Judge Temin was fair and very professional in his demeanor. He handled the proceeding with grace and reviewed the information in an unbiased manner

Judge: Christopher B McNeil
2/18/2014 6:22:15 PM

Not only is he insensitive, he is misogynistic. He needs to be impeached if he hasn't already lost his ALJ seat.

Mike Reynolds
Judge: Larry A Temin
2/4/2014 7:24:40 PM

Honorable? His hearings are pointless. He doesn't listen to the claimants, has made up his mind long before the claimant is given an opportunity to testify. He is paid to be a "judge", to examine all evidence and make decisions based upon the evidence. Instead, he always adheres to DDS's determination, unless your client has taken a sudden turn for the worse. Has zero imagination

Judge: Monica LaPolt
2/4/2014 12:00:43 PM

I thought she was very nice and understanding. She was very knowlegable about my file and all the evidence included. I have not yet receieved a decision, but felt she was fair during the hearing.

Peter A. von Volborth
Judge: Larry A Temin
1/30/2014 1:36:41 PM

Judge Temin is a good friend and former High School class mate. He is honorable and displays great integrity. The comment above is unwarranted and totally out of character.

Judge: Gregory G Kenyon
1/25/2014 10:59:33 AM


Precious Symphony
Judge: Kevin J Detherage
1/20/2014 7:32:40 PM

Very smart judge and very competent. Decisions are fair, objective, and well-reasoned. He takes the time to hear the issues and renders solid decisions.

Judge: Kenneth Wilson
1/10/2014 11:31:49 PM

Fair, Objective, and Thorough.

Judge: Kenneth Wilson
8/28/2013 9:17:30 AM

was great

David Freudenthal
Judge: Deborah Smith
6/14/2013 7:02:27 PM

Still honest and fair.

Judge: Kevin J Detherage
6/8/2013 5:13:08 PM

This guy doesn't have a clue. That he has been appointed to this type of position without having any background in Social Security law is a testament of all that's wrong with the federal judiciary. Unfortunately, the bottom line here is that he simply isn't very smart. His decisions repeatedly ignore the issues critical to just resolution of the claimants' respective claims and typically go off on irrational and bizarre tangents. He has no idea how to conduct a hearing in a timely manner and is incapable of focusing in on questions that bear some materiality to the issues at hand. God help you if you draw this moron as your judge because you will need all the hope He can provide you.

Judge: Vincent Misenti
4/19/2013 6:30:55 AM

This ALJ challenged my question to the claimant as to what restrictions his doctor had given him. The ALJ said the question was not admissible because it was hearsay. What does this say about his knowledge about administrative/SS hearings

Judge: Vincent Misenti
4/12/2013 8:12:37 PM

Misenti was an ALJ for the California Department of Social Services, widely regarded as the worst in the state. He doesn't listen, learn or reason, and thinks most claimants/applicants are malingerers.

Judge: Christopher B McNeil
4/3/2013 1:28:11 PM

He has stepped over the line, in writing, putting testimony into the mouth of a witness that said witness was not qualified to and in fact did not make. Now is the time to review his decision in your case for obvious legal error constituting misconduct. If he's done it once, he's done it before. For misconduct that violates legal ethics and/or judicial canons, a grievance can be filed with the Ohio State Bar Association.

Judge: Anne Shaughnessy
4/2/2013 2:56:30 PM

She has the personality of a rock!

Judge: Monica LaPolt
3/18/2013 2:45:24 PM

Her numbers say it, 25% you are going in just to make a record to appeal. She will interrupt you often. She pulls a lot of negatives out of the file so be prepared for drug/alochol and yes prison time even though it is outside the time frame of an AOD or PFD. She will also have the VE classify work as PRW although it doesnt fit SS definitions of PRW. If your client worked doing anything at all for any length of time it is PRW.

Judge: Monica LaPolt
3/18/2013 2:39:59 PM

She is the new CJ in Indy. VERY NICE!!! But she specifically asked me to let the other attorneys know that she expects you and the claimant to be at hearing and ready to go 30 minutes prior to the hearing time. The notice says that, and she EXPECTS that! She asks most questions, then turns it over to attorney. AND she told me she does not want me to get testimony regarding what doctors have told them, or what she could read in the medical evidence.

Judge: Monica LaPolt
3/18/2013 2:39:20 PM

nice judge, she knows the file, usually will let you cover sections on limitations and adl's. Moves quickly through the hearing.

Judge: Donald G Smith
3/15/2013 4:36:47 PM

He scares me, but I trust him at the same time. I just Hope he doesn't believe what the medical expert wrote in my interrogratoy! The medicaid doctors at the beginning thought i was crazy, and i became very upset when one of them said I was just looking for drugs, I cursed at her and said no i want to go back to work so i can support my family! With a few F words, so of course the medical expert blew that up out of proportion.

Judge: Christopher B McNeil
2/15/2013 10:23:17 AM

True Karma would be for Judge McNeil to have to live with only a few of the disabilities of those to whom he denies any assistance. He should be ashamed of himself.

Judge: Gilbert A Sheard
1/23/2013 7:31:53 AM

An old sweetheart, really. For some reason, he makes me think of old girlfriends with whom I didn't try hard enough.

Judge: Larry A Temin
1/23/2013 5:05:17 AM

He has the demeanor of a funeral director with an upset stomach, as if a whole lemon is permanently caught in his throat.

Judge: Christopher B McNeil
12/7/2012 4:53:07 PM

I have to agree with the above reviews. The average rate of Approvals in the entire country is 45%. He only approves 20%...should be investigated, but of course he won't be because he's not giving out the government's money.

Fred F.
Judge: Monica LaPolt
12/4/2012 1:11:03 AM

I had Judge LaPolt as my disability judge and thought that she ignored my medical records and letters from employers about my disabilities.I am a diabetic and have denegenitive disc disease the lower 3 discs in my back are black on xrays and MRI's.She ignored these findings in all of my evidence presented to her.Her letter to me in my denial letter were very upsetting and I have lost my house and wife for her unprofessionable findings.I hope she gets into another type of law before she ruins more lives like mine.

Judge: Christopher B McNeil
8/16/2012 10:42:29 AM

I feel really bad for anyone who gets stuck dealing with this judge. He will try every little way to deny a case despite medical evidence as clear as a bell right in front of his face. Apparently the medical examiners findings and opinion's mean nothing to this jack***

Judge: Gilbert A Sheard
8/9/2012 9:17:05 AM

My favorite ALJ. Runs a very efficient, pragmatic hearing.

Judge: Daniel Dadabo
8/2/2012 6:12:27 AM

Dear Judge Daniel Dadabo, I wanted to thank you for given me the chance to take back and regain control of my life. You and Nash Disability Law and North River mental Health, Illinois Masonic and Old Irving Park Medical have helped me under stand a part of my life that I didn't not believe. My life long struggles with mental illines and bullying and abuse have not been easy and I suspect that with continued therapy and help from the SSA I can become a productive and postive individual again. I didn't want to admit there was anything wrong, bipolar disorder and schizophrenia and autisim are not thing that you want to tell people there is such a stgma around that poeple either shun you or attack you and abuse you, which I have experienced my whole life til this day. Every day is a struggle just to be able to put close to clean myself properly, even being able to talk to some are accept a simple hug or hand shake any time some seems out of order I can become enraged or scared like a child. It makes it impossible to have any sort of relationships or to go to school or hold on to a job or go shopping! Once Again I would ask for your continued help along with help from Nash Disability and the SSA perhaps I can get better and get the help I need repair my life and take back control of my life from those who have taken so much away from me! Best regards, Gregory Tarczynski

Judge: Donald G Smith
7/19/2012 6:19:27 AM

I concur. He seems to have a problem accepting VA opinions. Will often send out interrogatories and ask questions like- does claimant's impairment meet a listing. If they did meet a listing , most cases would not be at ODAR.

Judge: Donald G Smith
6/8/2012 1:30:29 PM

Comes from somewhere in Kentucky (I think)- has the cutest Southern accent and he's sweet as pie. Don't be fooled: he'll deny for reasons completely foreign to me. He almost always send claimant to pre-hearing consultative exams, or send for medical interrogs. Sometimes he uses them; sometimes he doesn't. I have not seen any particular M.O. with him. Just watch out....

Judge: Kenneth Wilson
5/23/2012 1:39:49 PM


Judge: Christopher B McNeil
5/22/2012 6:11:10 AM

he really is a **** joke

Judge: Christopher B McNeil
4/20/2012 2:10:22 PM

This ALJ's behavior matches his low approval rating. His written decisions are a joke as well. If you are an attorney or representative be prepared to read a decision that spends as much time arguing with you as it does discussing why he denied the claim. He is just another embarrassment for the agency.

Diane Elizabeth Butler
Judge: Daniel Dadabo
4/8/2012 11:36:06 AM

Judge Daniel Dadabo; I'm Diane Elizabeth Butler, the lady the wrote the following: ("You help me and because of your help I am on the road to healing and becomming a resourceful individual. Thank You Judge Daniel Dadabo. Sincerely, Diane Elizabeth Butler") Well with all that said...I need to speak with you regarding an issue. I'm being BULLIED. The statements I made above are Sincere and Truthful. As I make every attempt to HEAL AND BECOME RESOURCEFUL AGAIN; The adverse actions that are enforced against me could keep me sick to getting sicker and have to remain a liability to the administration. The deliberate action of those who are attacking me and continually working against me keeps me in a constant fight.Medically you know I cannot stay any long period in a constant "flight to fight" It will raise my cortisol and keep it high which will eventually cause another "CRASH" ---When what I'm doing to heal and become resourceful is really me staying discipline and focused. Please allow me to meet and speak with you... my home number is ***-***-****, cell: ***-***-**** Please speak with me.. I need your Wisdom and Guidance... Sincerely, Diane Elizabeth Butler

Diane Elizabeth Butler
Judge: Daniel Dadabo
4/2/2012 2:36:14 PM

You help me and because of your help I am on the road to healing and becomming a resourceful individual. Thank You Judge Daniel Dadabo. Sincerely, Diane Elizabeth Butler